The current tree protection mechanism (if there is one) simply fails to protect trees, even for Old and Valuable Trees.

Even assumed that the technical circulars and various ordinances are able to protect trees, a consolidated tree ordinance is still preferable.

The Conservancy Association is of the view that a tree ordinance should embody the following principles:

Principles

1. Trees, especially mature trees and woodland in the urban area or urban fringes, are important asset and should be protected. Woodland with important ecological or environmental value should be designated as Tree Conservation Area. The Area should not be void even when leased. Trees with unique cultural and historical value should also be protected.
    

2. Felling of a tree larger than a certain size should be approved by the responsible Authority. Written approval must be obtained before trees could be felled. Unauthorized tree felling will be penalized.
    

3. The process of tree felling application should be transparent. Tree felling larger than a certain scale should be disclosed to the public. The public should be duly consulted.
    

4. Planting trees in private lots should be encouraged. If the site is open to the public, the developer or owner should be compensated, such as by transfer of plot ratio.
    

5. Management and maintenance works of trees should be performed by qualified arborists. A professional body should be authorized and responsible for maintaining the standards and handling complaints.
    

6. As trees are public asset, there should be adequate and genuine community participation in tree protection and devising greening policy.